I Hate Artsy Website Navigation
I found out last week that I have become something of a web design stick in the mud. It was because of my friend Eddie Perez’’s review of JimCarrey.com. Fittingly the design and user experience of the site is as unique as the actor and as Eddie puts it,
The site was clearly designed to give visitors a chance to unearth the content through exploration. Cinematic transitions between pages, coupled with great use of sound effects and eerie background music make it seem as if you’re not just discovering the content on the site, but also the mind of Jim Carrey as well.
That same day I met a woman who’s website home page was a mosaic of randomly generated set of YouTube videos that expand when rolled over. For both sites I reacted violently against the design. I didn’t want to work so hard to discover I wanted the content that I was looking for and I wanted to find it easily and accessibly. My God, I thought, I’ve become Jakob Nielsen!
What made me such a curmudgeon? Maybe it’s the hours that I’ve spent in usability testing. Maybe it was the fights about the logic behind cues for wayfinding in website navigation, work that led me to consider writing a book about best practices? Maybe it’s that I lived though the early years of web design where an image of an office served as the metaphor for the navigation of a corporate website? Maybe I’m just old, but I like standard, left navigation, no bells and whistles web design. I don’t want to explore, I don’t want unique experience. I want to find things quickly and easily so that I can move on. Maybe it’s ADD?
Even the bottom navigation of Jim Carry’s site was not enough. I needed the nav easily accessed, spelled out and easy to understand. Maybe I have too many toolbars on my browser? I want what is the target of each link to be obvious and I want to get there fast. I’ve become a stick in the mud when it comes to that stuff. I am set in my ways and cringe at navigation that is spaced across the page beside little logos or pictures and clearly not governed by CSS. I know what I like and what I don’t and I’m not going to change.
Now, you damn kids, get off my yard!
Update: Yesterday Conor Brady shot another spitball at my love of highly usable web design and navigation in his post Web Design Has Changed Since 2000, Why Haven’t Evaluation Standards? Argh, back in my day….























